MVP Races Are Partly Marketing Campaigns With Bylines

MVP Races Are Partly Marketing Campaigns With Bylines - VDG Sports

In the 2014-15 MVP race, the Houston Rockets sent media members a “video book” for James Harden’s case, which Yahoo Sports’ Marc Spears shared publicly. Over highlight footage sat a single leading question: “Most Valuable Player, the man who means most to their team’s success. Is it James Harden?” That is not a press release. It is a campaign ad, produced by the team whose player stood to benefit and sent to the people who write about the award. theScore, which reported it, noted that the Golden State Warriors were taking the opposite approach with Stephen Curry, then Harden’s closest competitor, and letting his play do the talking. Not entirely: NBC Sports reported on May 4, 2015 that one MVP voter had switched from Harden to Curry after hearing the Warriors’ phone campaign, and asked how much credit Curry owed Golden State’s public relations staff.

How the Votes Actually Fell

2014-15 NBA MVP Voting, Top Five
Player First-place votes Total points
Stephen Curry, Warriors 100 1,198
James Harden, Rockets 25 936
LeBron James, Cavaliers 5 552
Russell Westbrook, Thunder Not listed 352
Anthony Davis, Pelicans Not listed 203
Source: ESPN and AP, via ABC7. 130 first-place votes were cast.

Curry won the award with 100 of 130 first-place votes, and Harden’s second-place finish was the closest runner-up showing in four years, according to NBC Sports. Nobody can say how many ballots the campaigns moved, and this piece will not pretend to. The point is that the pitching was in the room.

Stephen Curry of the Golden State Warriors on the court during a game
Photo: IC Photo / Depositphotos

The Hashtag Loop

Lobbying is not confined to voters’ inboxes. On January 9, 2015, a Raptors TV play-by-play announcer spent a Sportsnet telecast of a loss to the Hornets repeating “Kyle Lowry Hashtag NBA Ballot” at least 11 times, by Sports Illustrated’s count, with a full-screen voting graphic flashed at least twice and appeals aimed at Canadian viewers. That campaign was for the All-Star fan vote, not for MVP, so it belongs in a different category from the video book, but the logic is the same. Bucks guard Kendall Marshall, watching, wrote on Twitter, “I understand you wanna push your players for All-Star but geez, can we enjoy the game?” A Globe and Mail columnist wrote that the Raptors seemed to be taking their collective eye off the ball, and added, “That’s why we agreed a long time ago that popularity contests are the pits.”

The Real Issue Is the Coverage

Here is the actual issue, and it is not that teams lobby. Of course they lobby. The award carries contract incentives and legacy weight, and lobbying is rational. The issue is how the resulting narratives get covered: “the MVP race is heating up,” “the case for Player X,” as if they come purely from on-court performance when some of that heat is generated in marketing departments and piped into inboxes and broadcast booths. The two examples above were reported at the time, which is to the credit of the reporters who flagged them. The better habit would be to say so inside the race coverage itself, to note, when a case is being pushed by a player’s own team, that it is being pushed by his own team.

A highlight video with a leading question is not evidence. A broadcaster’s hashtag loop is not color commentary. Nobody is asking media members to stop caring about MVP races. They are being asked to stop pretending the races run themselves.

VDG Sports, where Vince Douglas Gregory writes about the business and culture of sports, will keep an eye on who is pitching the MVP race and who is covering it.

The Friday Issue

The walk-backs they hoped you'd miss

Every Friday: the week's sports media walk-backs, deleted stories and quiet corrections, plus the VDG Sports reads behind them. Join and get the Clickbait Sports Journalism Survival Guide, ebook and audiobook, free.


Watch VDG Sports on YouTube

Sports media criticism, on video.