Sports Journalism Has an Ethics Code — Here’s Why Newsrooms Treat It Like Fine Print

Sports Journalism Has an Ethics Code — Here’s Why Newsrooms Treat It Like Fine Print - VDG Sports
Rows of empty red theater seats leading up a dark staircase
Photo: Felix Mooneeram / Unsplash

The Associated Press Sports Editors’ ethics recommendations are, on paper, fairly specific. Editors and reporters should avoid activities or employment that might create a conflict of interest, or even the appearance of one; if it’s unclear whether something is a conflict, “lean toward avoiding that situation”; and if a reporter uses quotes gained secondhand, readers should be told. Then comes the part that undercuts all of it: “Of course, guidelines can’t cover everything. Use common sense and good judgment in their application.” The page calls its contents “benchmarks and suggestions for all members” and mentions no enforcement or consequence. Just a trust exercise, in an industry built on access and relationships.

When the Trust Exercise Fails

The Athletic’s handling of Dianna Russini this year is the case study in what happens when the trust exercise fails. On September 3, a review led by Mike Semel, the outlet’s editorial director for standards and quality, concluded that “Russini’s relationship with Vrabel was in clear violation of The Athletic’s standards,” referring to Patriots coach Mike Vrabel, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. The review did not say what the relationship was. “We neither completed an investigation nor reached any conclusion about the nature of the full relationship,” it states, and Semel wrote: “Regardless of whether the relationship was romantic, it was a breach and should have been disclosed.”

Russini, in her resignation letter, said she did not accept “the narrative that has been constructed around this episode.” After the review came out she told The Athletic, as Pro Football Talk reported, “I stand by any and all reporting I’ve ever done in my career.” Vrabel, asked about the findings at Gillette Stadium, said he had “moved on,” per Boston.com.

The Timeline Is the Story

Page Six published photos of Russini and Vrabel at a boutique resort in Sedona, Arizona, on April 7, 2026. By the account in Boston.com, she waited two days after the New York Post confronted her before telling her editors. The Athletic’s first move was to back her: executive editor Steven Ginsberg initially called the photos “misleading” and lacking “essential context,” then wrote later that “as additional information emerged, new questions were raised that became part of our investigation,” per the reporting on the review. Russini resigned on April 14, a week after the photos ran.

The review took nearly five months and went through everything bearing her byline or crediting her reporting, according to Boston.com. Only about 46 of those 903 stories mentioned Vrabel or his teams, and just three of the 77 videos were Vrabel-specific, all lighthearted.

What The Athletic’s Review Covered
Item Reviewed Tied to Vrabel
Stories 903 About 46 mentioned Vrabel or his team (about 5%); all but about 15 were transactional or game coverage
Videos 77 3 were specific to Vrabel
Scoop City podcast episodes 204 Not broken out
Comparison stories About 75 Not applicable
Interviews About 25 outside, 14 staff Not applicable
Source: Boston.com, Sept. 3, 2026

Editor’s notes were part of the cleanup, and outlets describe them differently. The Sun-Times reports notes were added to four pieces, one story and three videos, while other accounts describe Semel recommending notes on the Vrabel videos because of the Post photographs. Treat the exact count as unsettled.

The Fix Everyone Announces

Notice what surfaced the problem: not an editor noticing a pattern, not a routine disclosure check, but photos in a tabloid. The standards existed the entire time, and by The Athletic’s own finding the relationship should have been disclosed. The review recommended that The Athletic tighten its standards, issue clearer guidelines and add a review with the standards editor to new-hire onboarding, per the reporting on the review. That is the fix every outlet announces after its own version of this story, and whether it gets adopted is not yet known.

That’s the actual scandal buried under the tabloid one: sports journalism’s ethics codes aren’t dormant because nobody wrote reasonable rules. They go dormant because enforcement tends to switch on only once a story is loud enough to force it, which means the fine print gets read out loud after it has already failed to do its job.

VDG Sports, where Vince Douglas Gregory writes about the business and culture of sports, will keep reading the fine print.

The Friday Issue

The walk-backs they hoped you'd miss

Every Friday: the week's sports media walk-backs, deleted stories and quiet corrections, plus the VDG Sports reads behind them. Join and get the Clickbait Sports Journalism Survival Guide, ebook and audiobook, free.


Watch VDG Sports on YouTube

Sports media criticism, on video.