ESPN Paid for a 24-Team Playoff, Then Got $140 Million a Year Back

ESPN Paid for a 24-Team Playoff, Then Got $140 Million a Year Back - VDG Sports

When the College Football Playoff expanded to 24 teams on Nov. 9, the first detailed account of the deal came from ESPN. Heather Dinich’s report, citing sources who “told ESPN,” said the network had signed a five-year deal worth nearly $1.7 billion to remain the playoff’s sole broadcast partner. The buyer broke the news of its own purchase. That is not a scandal. It is the starting point, and the rest of the deal reads differently once you keep it in mind.

The $140 Million Line

The same report, with ESPN’s Pete Thamel contributing, laid out the math. ESPN’s average additional payment is $345 million a year for five years, on top of the roughly $1.3 billion a year it already pays under the six-year, $7.8 billion contract signed in March 2024. But ESPN will effectively pay only about $205 million of that new money, because it gets $140 million a year back from the cancellation of the SEC, Big 12 and ACC championship games, whose TV rights ESPN owns. Fox, which holds the Big Ten title game, is expected to get about $50 million a year back.

The 24-Team Playoff Deal, by the Numbers
Item Amount
New deal Nearly $1.7 billion over five years
ESPN’s average additional payment $345 million a year
Existing contract $7.8 billion over six years, about $1.3 billion a year
Returned to ESPN from canceled SEC, Big 12 and ACC title games $140 million a year
ESPN’s effective new money About $205 million a year
Expected back to Fox for the canceled Big Ten title game About $50 million a year
Source: ESPN report, via TSN

So the conference championship weekend goes away, a weekend the SEC invented in 1992 and, as the Associated Press put it, “made billions from over the decades.” The AP summed up how the conferences got past that: “ESPN took care of the money problem.”

The Admission Nobody Led With

On the conference call, ESPN senior vice president Nick Dawson was asked whether a bigger playoff will make the regular season worth less. “In all honesty, it’s impossible to know for sure,” he said, adding that a lot of the responsibility will fall back to the schools and coaches.

Read that as a buyer. ESPN pays billions for regular-season college football. It just paid more for a postseason that may make those games matter less, and its own executive says nobody knows. That is an honest thing for an executive to say. It is also the most important sentence of the day, and it sat in the middle of the coverage, not at the top.

ESPN Owns the Argument, Too

The deal covers more than games. The CFP said the agreement also includes ancillary programming, including the selection show and the weekly ranking shows, according to Cox Media Group. ESPN’s own report added that the selection committee could expand its weekly list to 30 teams to show which programs are on the bubble.

ESPN sign lit up in Times Square, New York
Photo: Kathyimages / Depositphotos

That is the part to watch. A 24-team field with 19 at-large bids means more teams near the cut line and more weeks of “is this team in?” Every one of those arguments will happen on a show ESPN owns, about a bracket ESPN pays for, ending in games ESPN televises or sublicenses. ESPN can sublicense six of the 12 new games. The network is not just covering the debate over who deserves a spot. It holds the rights to the debate.

What the Fans Were Told

The AP noted that around 30 percent of the 68 power-conference schools will now have a shot at the title, and that Notre Dame loses its guarantee. CFP executive director Rich Clark said everyone involved was aware “that many fans aren’t in favor of expansion,” that the sentiment “was rolled into this decision,” and that they decided to move forward anyway.

What isn’t decided is what happens to the rest of the postseason. Asked about the bowl games ESPN owns and operates, Dawson said, “No decisions have been made at this time,” and added that there are “clearly still good TV windows to be had.”

Read the Coverage Like a Receipt

None of this means ESPN’s reporters got the facts wrong. The numbers above came from ESPN’s own reporting, and they were published. The point is narrower and more useful. When one company is the buyer, the broadcaster, the owner of the ranking shows and the party getting money back for the games being cut, its coverage of whether the change is good for the sport is not neutral ground. It might be right. It is still the seller describing the product.

Watch how the bubble debates are framed next fall, and keep the question ESPN’s own executive couldn’t answer in front of you: if the regular season ends up mattering less, who gets paid either way?

VDG Sports, where Vince Douglas Gregory writes about the business and culture of sports, will be watching the bubble shows with a calculator.

The Friday Issue

The walk-backs they hoped you'd miss

Every Friday: the week's sports media walk-backs, deleted stories and quiet corrections, plus the VDG Sports reads behind them. Join and get the Clickbait Sports Journalism Survival Guide, ebook and audiobook, free.


Watch VDG Sports on YouTube

Sports media criticism, on video.